P38 v. P51

This is an attempt to cleanse my palate after watching part of the debate.

The magic of the can…

Or better stated, the how to preserve food.

We are spoiled today, we go to the local supermarket and purchase almost any type of food we want, regardless of the growing season. It will be fresh and safe to consume.

My parents would not have dreamed of such luxuries when they were children.

We have a tradition of putting an orange into our Christmas stockings. Today, no big deal. When the tradition started, in my parents’ or grandparent’s time, it was a big deal. Those oranges were brought from far away at great expense. It was fresh and taste.

Yesterday, my wife went grocery shopping. We don’t eat as well as we did 4 years ago, inflation has eaten much of our purchasing power. Still, she was able to pick up fresh avocados and a bag of oranges.

If we don’t want fresh food, we can buy our food frozen. Still tasty. The quality is good, actually. Much better than I remember as a child.

But that food is not “shelf stable” and it will not last if the power goes out.

Smoked and dried foods will last a long time, but they too have issues, one of the large ones is that they are unprotected from the elements. It is no fun to find that your dried goods have been eaten by some critter.

Canned goods are, generally, shelf stable. They do lose nutritional value over time, but that time is measured in decades.

Early canning was putting your food into pottery and having it be preserved. Later, we learned to seal those containers to keep everything in.

The idea of a steel can, lined with tin, was patented in 1810. The basic idea is to take a thin sheet of steel, coat it in tin to stop it from rusting. This was rolled into a cylinder, bottom added and then sealed with high lead solder.

To say this was a revolution would be to understate the significance of this advancement. Food could be preserved for extended periods of time. It was easy to transport, easy to store, and the quality of the contents has gotten better and better.

Here is the important bit of trivia for us. Nobody had invented a can opener. The early cans were so heavy that the instructions explained how to open them with a hammer and chisel. Once the walls of the can became a bit thinner, other tools would be used.

The original battle ready can opener was the soldier’s trusty bayonet or other strong knife.

These tin cans were making their way into military supply chains, but not always for food.

By WW I, rations were being distributed in tin cans. But only partially. There were still large amounts of food that was not canned. Can openers were still large and clunky. Soldiers still resorting to their knives to open ration cans.

When WW II came around, the US had moved to tin cans for K-rations (Kitchen rations) and C-rations.

C-rations were intended to be short-term use. Instead, they turned into a primary food source for US G.I.

C-Rats consisted of 3 M-Units, 3 B-Units and 1 Accessory pack per day. The M, or Meat unit, was the primary source of protean. The B-Unit was fudge, biscuits, sugar, and drink mix.

The B units had a key attached to the bottom for opening the different cans. Later, they introduced the P-38.

The official name for this handy little device was “OPENER, CAN, HAND, FOLDING, TYPE I”. Where the P-38 and P-51 designations come from is a guess.

Some say it was from the 38 punctures it took to open an M-Unit. Of course, there is the possibility that it was named after the P-38 Lightning. When the larger P-51 was introduced, naming it after the P-51 Mustang seemed like a logical thing.

The P-38 isn’t much larger than a U.S. Penny. When the blade is folded open, it is positioned on the inside of the can rim. The notch is fitted into the rim, twisting the right hand forward will cause the hook to curve down and puncture the tin, making a short slice along the outside edge.

My preferred method is to turn the tin into the cutting hook. This means that I only make a single puncture, the rest are shearing cuts, extending the original puncture.

I don’t carry a P-38 or P-51. They are in the gear, ready to use. The last time I purchased them, I think I got 50 P-51 and 50 P-38s from Amazon.

All of my “multi-tool” knives have a can opener in them. I’m most used to my Swiss Army knife.

The SAK has a combination small screwdriver and can opener blade. The hook on the blade goes under the rim of the tin can. The hook goes on the inside of the tin can. Levering the knife up will puncture the top of the tin can and make that first slice.

I then rotate the can clockwise, into the hook, again allowing me to extend the cut from that single first puncture.

The number of times when it was faster to pull out the SAK to open a can than find a can opener in someone else’s kitchen is not insignificant.

So raise a glass to this lowly piece of steel. Over 80 years old, still going strong.


Comments

6 responses to “P38 v. P51”

  1. Tom from WNY Avatar
    Tom from WNY

    There’s a Swiss Army Knife in my kitchen for when the can opener doesn’t work on a non-compliant can. It is fairly quick to use.

  2. EagleAgg03 Avatar
    EagleAgg03

    I Almost added this set of comments in the last discussion, but it fits better here anyways.

    My first introduction to a manual hand can opener was with my first SAK, and I remember in Boy Scouts, my scoutmaster could get a #10 can open faster with his pocketknife than some of the boys could get them open with the kitchen style manual openers from the chuck boxes. I still prefer the SAK for a basic manual hand can opener and all of my “go-bag” style kits have at least a basic SAK or multi tool and they always including the knife, bottle opener/can opener set of tools, some have more, but those 3 are required.

    Also, the history of opening with hammer and chisel made me laugh. My wife tells a story about when she was a young teenager in the mid 90s and her family left her home alone for the weekend. While they were out the power went out for an extended period. She decided that her best option for dinner would be a cold can of soup; the only problem was that the only can opener in the kitchen was 120v electric powered … and the power was out. So being the problem solver she is, she took her can of soup down to her dad’s basement workshop and proceeded to use a hammer and screwdriver to get the can open. Now, almost 30 years later, I was able to let her know that she was using the oldest recommended procedure for the operation.

  3. After my first stint using a coworker’s P-38 can opener — when the office kitchen didn’t have one (a situation I later remedied myself by buying a good one and leaving it there for everyone to use) — I started carrying my Leatherman all the time. It has a can opener mostly similar to a SAK one, but the “blade” is oriented differently: turning the can clockwise makes a series of punctures, turning counter-clockwise extends the original cut. Both work just fine.

    (Technically, carrying the Leatherman in the office is not allowed by policy because of the knife blades. But in an office full of IT technicians, many of whom routinely assemble and disassemble equipment and open computer cases as part of their job duties, the number of people who didn’t have some kind of multi-tool is almost non-existent. It was just culturally accepted as something everyone knew but nobody talked about or reported.)

  4. I am able to use both of these can openers. I first learned from a friend, and while I dislike them, I also love them.

    I went to a reenactment event last year, and realized I’d left behind my can opener. I was swearing to myself and looking angrily at the two cans that I needed to get open, when I realized I had my little one in my purse. I dug around and found it. Voila, problem solved. 🙂 It may take me a while, and my fingers hurt after, but I can get it done.

  5. Straight Shootr Avatar
    Straight Shootr

    And a lot of the dimbulbs crewing the metal detectors in the courthouse will NOT allow you to have either a P-38 or a P-51 on your person.

    I’ve seen women go through the detectors that could cause a lot more damage with their long fake nails than that P-38 would ever cause..

  6. Slow Joe Crow Avatar
    Slow Joe Crow

    I grew up in relative luxury, we had an electric can opener, and an Ekco Miracle Roll, I must have been in middle school before I used P-38 and a pocket knife can openers. The twist style openers are much nicer, albeit bulkier